The Princess in Black
The Princess in Black by Shannon Hale and Dean Hale takes about 19 minutes to read aloud (2,079 words, about 2 sentences a page), and it lands best with children aged 5-8.
Measured read-aloud timeabout 19 minutes
- Words
- 2,079
- Sentences a page
- 2
- Re-read tolerance
- 5/5still fine on the fortieth reading
- Vocabulary
- 3/5a few new words
Check The Princess in Black on AmazonAffiliate link
The useful verdict
Why The Princess in Black works
Princess Magnolia leaves a tea party through a broom-cupboard chute to fight a monster, then goes back before anyone notices. It solves a specific problem - a child who wants a princess book and a monster book at once - and the double life is the joke, not the moral.
Before you buy it
ATOS 3.2 makes it a read-aloud for most fives rather than a solo read. The monsters are comic rather than frightening, but the illustrations are dark-toned and a few children read the cover as scary.
Themes: princesses, superheroes, monsters, secret identity, goats.
Same shape, new story
Books like The Princess in Black
Matched by length, refrain, sentence density, and listener—not just subject.
The Princess in Black and the Perfect Princess Partyabout 18.5 minutes · 5/5 re-read
Mercy Watson to the Rescueabout 17.5 minutes · 5/5 re-read- Zoey and Sassafras: Dragons and Marshmallowsabout 75.5 minutes · 4/5 re-read
Owl Diaries: Eva's Treetop Festivalabout 23 minutes · 4/5 re-read
Babymouse: Queen of the World!about 16 minutes · 4/5 re-read
The Knight at Dawnabout 48.5 minutes · 3/5 re-read
Ivy and Beanabout 71 minutes · 4/5 re-read
Yasmin the Explorerabout 5 minutes · 4/5 re-read
Phoebe and Her Unicornabout 77 minutes · 5/5 re-read
Straight answers
Questions parents ask about The Princess in Black
- How long does it take to read The Princess in Black aloud?
- About 19 minutes at an unhurried pace, from a word count of 2,079. Reading it fast shaves perhaps a third off; stopping for questions on every page can double it.
- What age is The Princess in Black actually for?
- Ages 5-8 in our testing, which is narrower than the publisher's range. With 2 sentences a page and vocabulary at 3 out of 5, it asks for that much attention span and no more.
- Does The Princess in Black survive being read on repeat?
- Yes - this is one of the few that is still fine on the fortieth reading, which is why it scores 5 out of 5 with us.
- Is The Princess in Black a good book for a child who will not sit still?
- It helps that it has a refrain a child can join in with. Those three features are what keep a wriggling toddler listening, far more than the subject matter does.